A Survey on AI-Driven Energy Optimization in Terrestrial Next Generation Radio Access Networks

Year
2024
Abstract

This survey uncovers the tension between AI techniques designed for energy saving in mobile networks and the energy demands those same techniques create. We compare modeling approaches that estimate power usage cost of current commercial terrestrial next-generation radio access network deployments. We then categorize emerging methods for reducing power usage by domain: time, frequency, power, and spatial. Next, we conduct a timely review of studies that attempt to estimate the power usage of the AI techniques themselves. We identify several gaps in the literature. Notably, real-world data for the power consumption is difficult to source due to commercial sensitivity. Comparing methods to reduce energy consumption is beyond challenging because of the diversity of system models and metrics. Crucially, the energy cost of AI techniques is often overlooked, though some studies provide estimates of algorithmic complexity or run-time. We find that extracting even rough estimates of the operational energy cost of AI models and data processing pipelines is complex. Overall, we find the current literature hinders a meaningful comparison between the energy savings from AI techniques and their associated energy costs. Finally, we discuss future research opportunities to uncover the utility of AI for energy saving.

Summary

AI techniques used to cut mobile network energy use often carry their own energy cost, which is rarely factored in. This survey compares how commercial next-generation terrestrial RAN deployments model power usage, categorises emerging power-saving methods by domain (time, frequency, power and spatial), and reviews attempts to estimate the running energy cost of the AI methods themselves. It finds that real power-consumption data is hard to obtain due to commercial sensitivity, that comparing energy-saving methods across systems is very difficult, and that the energy cost of the AI itself is usually overlooked — so today's literature can't really tell you whether AI-driven energy savings are worth their own energy cost.

bibtex
@article{sthankiya2024aisurvey,
author = {Kishan Sthankiya and Nagham Saeed and Greg McSorley and Mona Jaber and Richard G. Clegg},
title = {A Survey on AI-Driven Energy Optimization in Terrestrial Next Generation Radio Access Networks},
journal = {IEEE Access},
year = {2024},
volume = {12},
pages = {157540--157555},
doi = {10.1109/ACCESS.2024.3482561}
}
Authors
Kishan Sthankiya, Nagham Saeed, Greg McSorley, Mona Jaber, Richard G. Clegg
Venue
IEEE Access